|Without Liquid Liner
With Liquid Liner
MAC Satin Taupe (metallic purpley taupe): Inner two-thirds of lid to crease
MAC Nocturnelle (dark purple with shimmer): Outer third of lid to crease, and line bottom lashes
MAC Kid (matte light brown — two shades darker than yor skintone): Blend crease and transition
MAC Vanilla (matte off white): Highlight
MAC Vex (multi-color shimmer): Inner corner
MAC Carbon (matte black): Line top lashes
You don’t have to purchase these shadows necessarily… Just use something you have that is similar in color and finish.
In the first picture I used a matte black eyeshadow (Carbon) on a small angled brush (MAC 208) to line my eye and create a small wing… You can stop there for a more natural look, or you can use the shadow as a guideline when creating your winged eyeliner using liquid or gel liner. I like to put on one light coat of mascara before using liquid or gel liner because it keeps my lashes out of the way.
I hope this was helpful and I will be experimenting with different lighting to take the best pictures possible for future looks.
HAPPY NEW YEAR!